Nuno,
I could also say to you "It's amazing that someone in charge of a 4K uv a day site would make such a dramatic infrastructure change without testing it locally and planning a proper upgrade path".
K2 is a complete replacement of the content component of Joomla and as such, no-one should expect that the transition will be seamless. There are definitely some things that Joomlaworks could do to ease the transition but blaming them for this is not called for (try any other CCK out there, you'll run into the same things).
As far as how long it takes Google to remove old pages from its index, there is no guaranteed timeframe. Could be couple of days for some URLs, could be months for others. Even if this happens rapidly, you will most likely loose page ranking and that can take a really long time to regain (not to mention that it's not just Google that's affected but every site and person that had a link to your old pages too).
If you don't want to learn about 301s running a 4k uv/day site then don't blame anyone else on loosing traffic.
--Olivier Nuno Nogueira said:
It's amazig K2 developers have not predicted this in advance..
At least, it should be clear that if you install K2 in your Joomla website, your traffic will disappear from one day to the other! Currently, my website traffic dropped from 4K uv per day to 1,2K...
What if I just trash the whole Joomla content and submit a site map to google? How long will take to rebound?
Thanks Olivier Karfis, I'll check that tool!