Depending on how you've structured your content, you can set Usergroups so that specific users within a specific usergroup will have Comment Permissions per category while guests would have comment restrictions.
To limit comment permissions per article based on guest/registered (refer to example below)
Example Category A contains Article A, B and C
Registered User CAN comment on Category A - Articles A - C
Guest User CAN Comment on Category A - Article A and C
Guest User CANNOT Comment on Category A - Article B
I'm not too sure you can do this with K2 alone, however a custom permissions re-write could be made up to display the comment box to specific usergroups and hide it from other usergroups (probably only guests)
- - - - - - - - - - -
What version of Joomla and K2 are you running?