First of all I would like to point out that I love k2, it is handy to make more advanced sites with joomla.
However lately my office has noticed either a serious flaw. Pages will get duplicate url's witch cripples any SEO benefit k2 might give.
I have made a stack overflow question at stackoverflow.com/questions/16593121/joomla-k2-seo-consistency going into some detail.
Even if it is a tag view, witch is our way to get around the fact that you cannot use multiple categories on one item. You run into the problem that each tag takes the page under its menu structure. We have looked into some SEF solutions but short of adding template overrides on all links there does not seem to be a simple solution.
We develop through a local server, so it is hard for me to show examples. The easiest way to replicate the issue is to create 2 tags and 2 menu items that list the tag view. Then add one k2 item that will have both tags. In both tag views the page will go to the-tag/item and the-tag2/item witch is a duplicate page for one item.
This problem also appears in category views but is less apparent. Normally if you have the category set to use only one category any items that are under a different category should 404 if you navigate to the page forcibly. However it does not. Here is an example of how to replicate it.
Create 2 categories and 1 k2 item for each category. This is the general structure:
Category 1
Item 1
Category 2
Item 2
If you make a menu item to reference each category you can navigate to the item like so:
category-1/item-1
However the problem lies in that the following link will work:
category-1/item-2
The reason I wanted to bring this up is I find myself rewriting k2 far to often. It is a great plugin but there is a lack of documentation for such a feature rich plugin. Under the documentation tab here there is a few video tutorials some simple articles. Nothing diving into the functionality to give developers a starting point.
Most of the time if I need to lets say pull items into a dynamic list, I use a file separate from Joomla to manually query the database, creating a plugin usually takes too much time and I would not even know where to begin to find out how to comunicate with the k2 plugin.
Our company has been working with k2 for a number of projects now and I feel the it has a lot of potencial. I will try to get into more detail of the problems we found. It could be a major bug, or just something we are missing a key factor in that might be good to have in some type of documentation.
However lately my office has noticed either a serious flaw. Pages will get duplicate url's witch cripples any SEO benefit k2 might give.
I have made a stack overflow question at stackoverflow.com/questions/16593121/joomla-k2-seo-consistency going into some detail.
Even if it is a tag view, witch is our way to get around the fact that you cannot use multiple categories on one item. You run into the problem that each tag takes the page under its menu structure. We have looked into some SEF solutions but short of adding template overrides on all links there does not seem to be a simple solution.
We develop through a local server, so it is hard for me to show examples. The easiest way to replicate the issue is to create 2 tags and 2 menu items that list the tag view. Then add one k2 item that will have both tags. In both tag views the page will go to the-tag/item and the-tag2/item witch is a duplicate page for one item.
This problem also appears in category views but is less apparent. Normally if you have the category set to use only one category any items that are under a different category should 404 if you navigate to the page forcibly. However it does not. Here is an example of how to replicate it.
Create 2 categories and 1 k2 item for each category. This is the general structure:
Category 1
Item 1
Category 2
Item 2
If you make a menu item to reference each category you can navigate to the item like so:
category-1/item-1
However the problem lies in that the following link will work:
category-1/item-2
The reason I wanted to bring this up is I find myself rewriting k2 far to often. It is a great plugin but there is a lack of documentation for such a feature rich plugin. Under the documentation tab here there is a few video tutorials some simple articles. Nothing diving into the functionality to give developers a starting point.
Most of the time if I need to lets say pull items into a dynamic list, I use a file separate from Joomla to manually query the database, creating a plugin usually takes too much time and I would not even know where to begin to find out how to comunicate with the k2 plugin.
Our company has been working with k2 for a number of projects now and I feel the it has a lot of potencial. I will try to get into more detail of the problems we found. It could be a major bug, or just something we are missing a key factor in that might be good to have in some type of documentation.