I figured it out. I compared the original K2 files in components/com_k2/templates/default to the template override files in my template directory. I could see that for some reason my template override files were using the date format:...
Your idea was correct! When I view the blog with "?template=atomic" at the end of the URL the dates show correct. So how do I fix it so the dates show in J 2.5 date format?!
After migrating my site to a new server suddenly all my dates above my items have a weird format and illegible dates. I am running Joomla 2.5.6, have reinstalled with the latest version 2.5.7 again, cleared cache, etc and the issue...
More