It seems this was actually a template issue! For those who may encounter the same problem with any J51 Joomla templates and want to use K2, add this bit of code to the template custom CSS parameters, and it should work just fine :)
Hello, First off LOVE K2! I am so happy I decided to install this fantastic module, as I feel it fits my website perfectly! I recently updated Joomla from 1.6 to it's latest stable version (thanks to jupgrade) and am re-vamping my site...
More