Turned out to be a javascript error from mootools.js which was included in the extension Modalizer. Fortunately, I was able to disable the .js using the advanced parameters within the Modulizer extension and now the comments section works....
I cannot post comments either. I have the August 6th, 2009 - v2.0 version on Joomla 1.5.9. At present registered users are allowed to post comments. There is no error message - after clicking on the submit button the icon (rotating arrows)...
More