This tweak with Items in modal box can work well.
Spiderf find real (full) URL´s, follow and index them. (need to be checked if Google doesn´t threat "iframe" still as extern domain. Because of that i said you need to read more new information, not something back in 2003-2005)
And you need to find at Joomla forum if is it possible (with .htaccess, some ad to this code in tweak, or with robots.txt) force spiders to disregard that "&tmpl=component" at the eend of URL´s.
If it is possible then you have real indexing, Items as it would be without popup, with navigation, menu, modules, etc...
If someone find your site at Google, click on it and land in Item as it is in modal box. Then there it ends. You lose a viisitors, because he/she cannot go nowhere else in your site.